Claude connects to one Salesforce org fine. Add a second on the same MCP server and it says the URL already exists. The fix is free: put the org’s My Domain in the connector URL, and every org gets its own.
On this page
- The problem
- The URL format
- Production and sandbox
- Set up Salesforce
- Add the connector
- Still failing?
- Gotchas and FAQ
“A server with this URL already exists.”
You connected Claude to one org. Then you added a second org on the same MCP server, and Claude refused. It isn’t OAuth. It’s the URL.
Claude identifies a custom connector by its URL. The generic Salesforce hosted MCP URL for sobject-all is the same for every org, so the second connector looks like a duplicate of the first. You don’t need a paid third-party tool to fix that. Salesforce already supports an org-specific URL: put the org’s My Domain in it.

Prefer to read? Everything in the video is written out below.
Use the org-specific URL.
My Domain after /d/, an environment segment if the org needs one, then the server name.
https://api.salesforce.com/platform/mcp/v1/d/{my_domain}/{environment-if-needed}/{full-server-name}| Org type | Environment segment |
|---|---|
| Production, trial | None |
| Sandbox | /sandbox/ |
| Developer, scratch | /develop/, /scratch/ |
Production and sandbox.
Same server, different orgs, different URLs.
Production or trial, My Domain salesforcemasterclass, server platform/sobject-all:
https://api.salesforce.com/platform/mcp/v1/d/salesforcemasterclass/platform/sobject-allSandbox called uat on the same org. The sandbox My Domain is the production one, two hyphens, then the sandbox name, and the URL gets /sandbox/ too:
https://api.salesforce.com/platform/mcp/v1/d/salesforcemasterclass--uat/sandbox/platform/sobject-all
Set up each org in Salesforce.
Every org you connect needs its own MCP server activated and its own External Client App.
- Setup → MCP Servers. Activate the server you want, e.g.
sobject-all. That name is the last part of the URL. - Setup → External Client App Manager. Create an app for Claude with the recommended OAuth scopes and callback URL from Salesforce’s hosted MCP docs.
- Copy that app’s consumer key and consumer secret.

Add the custom connector.
Customize → Connectors → Add → Add custom connector.
- Name it after the org: FSC Trial Org, Client UAT. With several connectors, clear names save you.
- Paste the org-specific URL.
- Paste that org’s consumer key and secret, save, and authenticate.

Run down this list.
- MCP server activated in the target org
- External Client App created in that same org, with the right scopes and callback URL
- Consumer key and secret from that org, not another one
- My Domain spelled correctly
- Sandbox: both the
--sandboxnamesuffix and/sandbox/ - Server name at the end matches the one you activated
Once Claude can see your orgs, the source analysis Claude skill is a good first thing to point it at.
The questions people ask.
What’s the URL format?
https://api.salesforce.com/platform/mcp/v1/d/{my_domain}/{environment}/{server}. Leave the environment out for production and trial orgs.Why “A server with this URL already exists”?
Do production and trial orgs need an environment segment?
/d/{my_domain}/ to the server path.How do I write a sandbox My Domain?
salesforcemasterclass--uat. Plus /sandbox/ in the path.Separate credentials per org?
Claude is the new admin tool.
The Masterclass community is where I share what’s working with Claude and Salesforce, from migrations to everyday admin.
Know someone connecting Claude to more than one org?
Share on LinkedIn